The
Main Event keynote address was delivered by Dr. Michael Cox, senior
vice president and chief economist of the Federal Reserve Bank of
Dallas. This is an abridged and edited transcript of his remarks,
which were made with the assistance of numerous data exhibits which
are not available for publication.
A persistent theme
of Dr. Cox's speeches and publications is the fact that most of the
things we consume cost less and less in terms of the hours of work
needed to earn enough to acquire them. According to Cox, this trend
occurs at almost all income levels, and continues through boom times and
times of slower economic growth.
"A hundred years
ago, during the era of mass production, the United States was a leader
in the production of goods and equipment, and in transporting those
goods to the rest of the world. We excelled at that.
"That’s still going
on and global trade is still expanding, but the second great round of
innovation is in information. It used to cost $100 to send just a
10-word telegram across the ocean. Even as the price came down for
telegrams, Americans did not use the telegraph much. The average person
never sent one more than once every six years.
"Until recently, the
price of a long distance phone call, a 10-minute international call, did
not come down enough to be affordable. It cost a thousand hours of work
back in 1934 for a 10-minute international phone call. This came down
eventually to about six minutes, a tenth of an hour, of work. People now
in a foreign country don’t think too much about picking up the phone and
dialing their assistant.
"So we’re much more
connected, but the main way we’re more connected, that we communicate
internationally, is with e-mails. The number of e-mails sent across the
planet is up from almost none in 1995 to 11 trillion in 2006. By today,
it’s probably double that. I can be in Mexico, China, or Africa and
connect with somebody in a Starbuck’s in America.
"Now, if I’m a U.S.
company, I can have a back office shop in Bangalore or Hyderabad or
Chennai. Over in India, they’re working at night when it’s our day,
answering phone calls to fix our computers, among other things. I would
not recommend to many American students than they get a degree in
computer science. Twenty years ago that might have led to a relatively
high wage, but today they’re competing with Indian personnel.
"We are actually
doing remote surgery over long distances. In 2001, a doctor in New York
operated on a patient’s gall bladder in Strasburg, Germany. Five years
after that, a laptop in Boston actually was able to improve the
trembling in a surgeon’s hands as he operated on a patient in Milan.
"Our students are
being tutored by Indians. For $100 a month you can get trans-global
tutoring from a company named Tutor Vista.
"We’re traveling now
more than we used to. In 1950, only one person on average would arrive
in a foreign country for every 100 people who lived there. Today, it’s
12.
"So, what about the
by-products of all this globalization? Well, we're seeing the fastest
productivity growth in many years. The average productivity growth rate
for 130 years, from 1870 to 2003, was 2.3% on average. At that rate, it
takes 72 years for living standards to double.
"Since computers
were fully integrated into business operations, productivity growth has
been high, not just in the United States, but especially high in China,
India, and Eastern Europe. In only a couple of places in the world has
productivity growth slowed down, but that’s a function of the fact that
some countries are unwilling to go through the process of creative
destruction to remake themselves over and over.
"Another important
rend is the great moderation in the business cycle. We used to be in
recession a lot. In fact, over the period from 1853 to 1953, the U.S.
economy was in recession 40% of the time. Over 1,200 months, we were in
recession 409 months. But, since November of 1982, we’ve only had 16
months of recession. That’s only 5% of the time. We’re a much more
stable economy.
"Years ago, services
were not a very large part of the economy; only 25% of it. Now, they
account for 50%, so you have 50% of the economy being a very stable
sector. So, the overall economy is much more stable
"A fourth trend is
lower inflation. Inflation rates for industrialized countries used to be
very high, but today they're down to 2-3%. If today’s inflation rate
goes up to 3.5%, we throw up our hands and think, “Oh, that’s terrible.”
That's because we’re competing now with other countries for investments
worldwide. If we let our inflation rate get very large, we’re going to
lose customers for U.S. markets and U.S. investments. The competition
between central banks is a good reason inflation will stay low.
"Inflation
expectations have come down. If you remember the period during which the
inflation rate in America got up to 14% in the late 1970s, that burned a
lot of investors. People who had put their money in long-term government
bonds that yielded 2-3% found out that they had a capital loss on their
bonds. So, they said, “Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame
on me. I am not going to let you loan me that money again at those rates
for a long time."
"So they forced a
350-basis point premium, an inflation rate risk premium on government
securities for a long time. It finally got eradicated due to the
so-called "Greenspan effect" of monetary policy stable enough for people
to believe we could have long-term interest rates without long-term
inflation. The inflation risk premium eventually got down to zero. This
is as good as it gets for these low inflation expectations.
"One of the biggest
trends is the rise of China and India. Real GDP per capita in China was
roughly $700 per person in the year 1. In 1978, it was about the same.
For almost 2,000 years China went nowhere. Finally, they adopted
markets. They haven't reached Western levels yet, but they’re rising
rapidly.
"You know how much
difference it’s made to the world to incorporate Germany and Japan into
the world following the Second World War. Those two countries came on
strong, they were our competitors, and they provided products for us to
consume. It was very good for the world to have Japan and Germany as
competitors—and South Korea, as well.
"But Germany, Japan,
and South Korea together only have 260 million people. The U.S.
population is 304 million. Imagine what it is going to do with these 2.5
billion people in China and India joining the capitalist club, to have
40% of the world’s population suddenly become capitalist consumers and
producers, rather than just producing only what they can consume.
"People don’t live
in isolation anymore. When your production goes up, so does your
consumption. We've seen China’s production relative to GDP, its exports
relative to GDP, go from 2.5% to 37%. But their imports have gone up,
too, so they are demanding more from the rest of the world, as well as
supplying more to the rest of the world.
"The same thing’s
true of India. India has gone from exporting about 4% of their GDP to
exporting 20%, but their imports have gone up to 23%. They’re actually
running a trade deficit, buying more form the rest of the world. So this
is a real opportunity for America to sell stuff to 2.4 to 2.5 billion
people.
"We’ve spent 80-100
years developing a service economy. Only 18% of us in America work in
the goods-producing businesses: agriculture, manufacturing, mining, and
construction. But 82% of us work in the service business. We haven’t
been able to export our services very much because technology was not in
place to make it easy. Today, it is, so there’s going to be big growth
in export of service.
"The Bureau of
Economic Analysis has taken all the data on services exports and imports
to and from America and broken it down into 20 categories. The United
States has export surpluses in 15 of those 20 categories.
"We have a huge
surplus in our royalties for records and software products and so on. We
export five times as much in financial services as we import from the
rest of the world. Our financial business is in there selling stuff and
managing money for the rest of the world."
"In education,
they’re coming here to go to our schools more than we are going to
theirs.
"In the film
business, there's a big export surplus. You can actually download movies
from foreign countries now and we get money for that. The legal business
is exporting a lot more to the rest of the world than we are importing
in legal services.
"The biggest example
is industrial engineering. That industry is overseas making their
factories work, making their supply chain management work. Yes,
foreigners are making the goods and services, but who’s making the
equipment talk to each other?
"We import four
times as much insurance service as we export. A lot of this is
reinsurance. There is a great opportunity for America to be selling its
insurance to the rest of the world, all kinds of insurance, including
property insurance. 100 million people in China live in China’s top 10
cities. Every week in Shanghai two office buildings of 35 or more floors
are completed, and that’s scheduled to happen for the next six years.
And that’s just the office space and the commercial space. There’s a lot
of property left here.
"The residential
construction is changing in China, too, to where folks are finally going
to have enough money to be able to build a decent sized house, and then
they’re going to want to insure it.
"If we don’t look
outward form the United States to the rest of the world, from our local
to a global market, we’re giving up 21 customers for every one that we
have. We’re 4.5% of the world population; we only have one out of every
22 people living here in America. Twenty-one of every 22 potential
customers live out there.
"Another trend is
greater resources demand. There’s a very tight correlation between
income and oil consumption and all kinds of resource consumption.
There’s just no way around this at least for a decade or two. World
demand for oil will be rising and the putting upward pressure on prices.
"Rising wealth,
rising world wealth, is another trend. We’re not the only ones getting
richer anymore. In North America, we expect that wealth is going to
increase. But the biggest increases in percentage terms are going to be
in the Middle East, 9.5%, because of oil prices, but also in the
Asia-Pacific region, 8.5%.
"We have an
increasing number of people whose net worth exceeds a million dollars.
There are about nine million millionaires in America today. In terms of
investable assets, the figure is six million millionaires. Wealth is
going up across all categories.
"The way in which
wealth is held is continuing to rise. I hear all the myths all the time
about how we’re becoming a very indebted nation, but that’s just looking
at one side of the balance sheet, that’s just looking at liabilities.
"On the asset side,
household net worth relative to income has been increasing. Net worth
has been increasing faster than income. Net worth is more volatile than
income but it’s higher.
"The importance of
education and knowledge is rising. We are increasingly in a world where
what you know is what matters, not just your knowledge gained in school
but what you’ve learned elsewhere.
"Two very strong
factors in well-being are education and experience. Suppose you drop out
of junior high. You’re young, 25-34, you make $22,000 a year. Thirty
years later, you’re making $5,000 a year more, not much more at all.
But, suppose you get a professional degree? You're in the same age
group, still making as much, but you see a huge increase in your income
over your lifetime, a $70,000 increase in income.
"This is the most
egalitarian economy we ever had. There's gold in them books and you just
mine it out. You earn what you learn.
"We need to use our
creativity, our imagination, to think of new ways to do business. Most
of the people getting rich in America today are imagination-age moguls.
Bill Gates who did not use his analytic power to invent Windows, but he
did recognize that it would be something the world would use and so. The
same thing is true of Jeff Bezos, who imagined a new way of acquiring
books.
"Imagination and
creativity have risen above analytic reasoning in terms of value, but
the highest value now is placed on people skills and emotional
intelligence. Folks that know how to manage a labor force. Folks that
know how to inspire people. We need to tap the knowledge of business
which we’ve garnered over years and years of operating a capitalist
economy.
"We’re the most
diverse nation in the world in terms of our labor force, so, we should
know how to get along with one another. We’re much more egalitarian this
way than many other nations, and in our day-to-day jobs we’re already
more people-oriented. This is our natural comparative advantage.
"The next trend is
the rising economic power of women. Some 72% of the new veterinarians
coming out of schools are women, 68% of new pharmacists are women, half
of doctors, 45% of the MBAs.
"The rise of
declining average cost industries is an important trend. In old economy
industries, the cost of doing business turned up after awhile. This does
not characterize much of today’s economy. Today’s enterprises tend to
have high fixed costs and low marginal costs.
"The cost of bring a
new pill to market is a billion dollars--for the first pill. The second
pill? Fifteen cents. Windows NT cost $250 million to design for the
first copy. Second copy: 50 cents.
"This means that the
average cost curve goes down over a range of output. As we add the world
to demand, we can each be charged just a little bit to cover fixed
costs. This is true in software, it’s true in medicine, it’s true in
hardware, and it’s true in microchips. Poor countries are able to get
stuff at very low cost so they’re able to raise their living standards
very quickly.
"Products are also
diffusing into the economy much faster than they used to. In a few
years, just a few years, Internet use spread throughout America and
throughout the world. The same is true for cell phones. This is because
these are declining average cost industries.
"Leisure is
increasing. The average work week in America in 1830 was 76 hours. Six
10-hour days was the average week in 1870. In 1830 it was six 12-hour
days plus 4.5 hours on Sunday. It's down to 34 hours in American today.
In 1870, people worked 61% of the time they were awake; today, we work
28% of the time we’re awake.
"We spend more time
watching TV than in the past. We go to more movies. We have more adult
softball teams, twice as many golfers, 14 times more Americans taking
cruises, and 3½ times as many amusement parks."